Naughty or Nice – Christmas Silent Singer Review

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Email
Print
I’m guessing a lot primaries this week will be working on preparing for singing in Sacrament Meeting on Christmas Sunday (I’m curious – is anyone holding 3-hour block meetings on Christmas Sunday and need a lesson plan for that day?).
 
Our primary was asked to sing Away in a Manger combined with the 2 other primaries that attend our building (we are having a joint meeting Christmas morning – should be fantastic!).  So I’ve been brainstorming to come up with an activity that will keep the kids singing over and over and over again that has a low-prep Christmas-themed activity (no need to add singing time to all the crazy, right?).  So I came up with:
 
Naught or Nice using these guys:
 
Any form of Santa/Elf puppet, figure, etc. will work – I just have these.  I saw these homemade face puppets on FB HERE (thank you for sharing Alycia) that were DARLING and looked simple enough to re-create that would be fun for this activity:
 
Or if you want really low-prep, no prop is even necessary!
 
The activity is a spin-off of Silent Singer.  A child is called out into the hallway.  The primary chooses another child to be “naughty” and not sing.  They are to only mouth the words but make no sound (in essence, pretending to sing).  The child in the hallway is called back in and receives a prop, thus becoming Santa.  They are to figure out who is being “naughty” and not singing.  My little props have bells attached so I’ll just have them shake the Santa when they know who it is.  But it’s not essential.
 
When the naughty child is found, repeat with new children.  If you have big primaries, choose 2 or more kids to be Santa and 2 or more kids to be “naughty.”  I’ll tell the kids that only good singers will get to go out in the hall to be Santa and if anyone is being “naughty” when they weren’t chosen, will not be allowed to play Santa or officially be “naughty.”
 
If I find that it’s backfiring with the older kids, I’ll move to Alycia’s activity with omitting words instead and the chosen child has to decide what word was not sung.  Similar to my Word Nerd activity HERE.
 
I also printed a flip chart HERE that I’ll post on the board.  I will gradually remove pages from the chalkboard as we repeatedly sing the song.
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Email
Print

Make singing time easy!

Get it to go!

Singing time just got even easier!  With my Singing Time To-Go, all you have to do is print!  Be prepared for the entire month – every month!

Camille's Primary Ideas: Singing Time To-Go Membership

3 thoughts on “Naughty or Nice – Christmas Silent Singer Review”

    1. Junior Primary has been tricky for me with this game, but I say give it a go since every group is different. Maybe have 2-3 kids in the hall that can work together to find the 1 "naughty" singer.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Be prepared in singing time for the entire month – every month!  And all you have to do is print!

Recommended singing time supplies:

Camille's Primary Ideas: Choose the Right Singing Time Ideas

Teaching Choose the Right Song for Primary

Just like the title of this post says, make sure you choose the right singing time ideas!  Oh, how I love a good play on words ;).  But seriously, you can’t go wrong with any of these Choose the Right Primary singing time ideas!

Camille's Primary Ideas: Musical Math Primary singing time idea from the February 2024 Friend Magazine

Musical Math – February 2024 Friend Magazine

disruptive children.  So put those growing minds to work with some simple musical math singing time problems!  They’re simple to use during transition time, or in between songs during singing time, or whenever!

Sign up to join the singing time party:

New Primary Music Leader?

Sign up to receive emails to get you started in singing time!

Make singing time easy!

Get it to-go!

Singing time just got even easier!  With my Singing Time To-Go, all you have to do is print!  Be prepared for the entire month – every month!

Gain access to ALL my free lesson plan printables

    Hundreds of printables organized by song title and category that coincide with my singing time lesson plan posts!