Whether you are familiar with the original Would You Rather game or not, you will LOVE this Would You Rather singing time review New Testament edition! Review ANY Primary songs using events, stories and parables found in the New Testament!

Several years ago, I created the original would you rather singing time review activity HERE.

That original version was a mix of Would You Rather questions from the scriptures and gospel topics. But this NEW Would You Rather singing time review activity is geared exclusively toward the New Testament! It coincides perfectly with what we’ve been studying all year in Come Follow Me!
Review Primary songs we’ve learned so far while also reviewing what we’ve studied in the New Testament! A total WIN WIN!!
This idea was sparked by a question on the PML FB page HERE. And I couldn’t help but create a version of my own!
Would You Rather Cards
For this review activity, you need the 10 Would You Rather cards. They contain these New Testament related questions:
- see Jesus walk on water or calm the storm?
- be healed from leprosy or an issue of blood?
- be a shepherd or a wise man?
- walk everywhere you go or fetch your water from a well?
- be the rich man that Jesus told to sell all he had or the widow who gave her last mite?
- eat loaves and fishes Jesus blessed drink the water Jesus turned into wine?
- be present at Jesus’ birth or His resurrection?
- hang out with Peter, James and John or John the Baptist?
- be a poor but loved fisherman or a wealthy but hated tax collector?
- watch the Savior suffer in Gethsemane or see Him die on the cross.
The cards print 2 to a page like this:

And also contain this cover sheet:

Access these printables at my Resource Library. Instructions for accessing the Resource Library are found at the bottom of this post.
Print on card stock, cut out and laminate (optional). Get more details on the singing time offices supplies I use and recommend HERE.

Susan Fitch
All the illustrations come from Susan Fitch. I LOVE her artwork as she makes us look SO good in singing time!! You can find several of her New Testament illustrations in her Etsy shop HERE.

Singing Time Review Activity
Before Primary hang the “Would You Rather…” cover page at the top of the board using magnets, tape or magnetic tape.
To play, simply read one of the cards then place it on the board. Children must choose which option they would rather do. Then quickly and quietly they must move to a side of the room according to their selection.
Once the 2 groups are formed based on what everyone would rather do, sing the song. Repeat with a new card, thus creating new groups while singing a new song as time permits.
Would You Rather Variations
- Point to one group then the other, trading as you point. So only one group sings at a time.
- Challenge each group to sing the best and afterwards, decide who sang it better.
- For large Primaries, try having one group face the back wall and the other group face the front wall instead of switching sides.
No Printer, No Problem!
If you would rather {see what I did there??}, no printer is necessary for this singing time review game! Simply call out the questions and have the Primary create groups.
More Singing Time Review Activities
Make sure to check out more singing time review activities and games HERE.

Check out this quick tutorial video for accessing the Resource Library:
These printables are filed on the Resource Library page under Category Title > Would You Rather.
8 thoughts on “Would You Rather Singing Time Review – New Testament Edition”
Why can’t I access the New Testament “Would you Rather?” I only see the Old Testament would you rather. Could you please help me?
Hi Sonya!
It’s in the Resource Library under Category Title > Would You Rather. The document is titled “New Testament Edition.” I hope that helps.
~Camille
Maybe it’s just me but I’m a little confused about what songs go with each question..
Hi Diane!
There’s no song with the questions. Simply ask a question, kids move to either side of the room depending on the answer then you sing your song. I hope that clarifies.
~Camille
I cannot access the Would You Rather cards for The New Testament. I have tried and gone to the Resource Library.
Melanie
Hi Melanie!
The printables you are looking for are filed on the Resource Library under Category Title > Would You Rather. You may be looking under Song Title instead of Category Title (if you are on mobile, scroll toward the bottom to find that). I tried emailing them to you but your email address came back as undeliverable. If I can get your email address, I’ll email them to you as well. I hope that helps.
~Camille
Hi Camille,
Could you email me the New Testament Would you rather cards? I would really appreciate it. celestehathaway6@gmail.com
Thank you,
Celeste Hathaway
Hi Celeste!
The printables are filed on the Resource Library under Category Title > Would You Rather. I’ve emailed you the direct link. I hope that helps.
~Camille